
Highland Park UMC in Dallas, Texas, Moves Toward Leaving UMC Amid Legal Dispute With Horizon Texas Conference
Highland Park United Methodist Church in Dallas, Texas, has been involved in a legal dispute with the United Methodist Church’s Horizon Texas Conference over changes to the church’s governing documents. According to one report, the church’s bylaws and state incorporation documents were changed in 2022, and the conflict centers on those changes.
Reports differ on the nature of the bylaw changes. One report says Highland Park allegedly modified its bylaws to allow for the possibility of withdrawing from the United Methodist Church. The church’s leaders assert that the conference was aware of the changes and did not object. Bishop Reuben Saenz disputes this and claims the conference was not informed.
Church leaders then called for a congregational vote on whether to withdraw from the denomination, following the dispute with the Horizon Texas Conference. They outlined their concerns and invited members to weigh in at a town hall meeting. Reports give the date of that meeting as October 11, and one gives it as October 12. They also differ on the year: one report is dated 2025, while another places the town hall on Sunday, October 11, 2026. A report on the gathering said about 800 people attended and that it took place amid an ongoing legal battle over the governing documents. Caroline Nowlin, chair of the Highland Park Church Council, said that leaving the United Methodist Church would be decided by a congregational vote rather than by the council. David McAtee, a council member, moderated the meeting and said the dispute centers on clergy selection and on whether the church can leave the denomination if members vote to do so. Church leaders’ invitation to members to speak before any vote reflects an effort at open dialogue within the congregation (Romans 12:18).
The Horizon Texas Annual Conference sued the church in August over its bylaws and corporate documents, according to one report. Reports do not agree on the sequence that followed, but one says the church’s announcement came three months after its dispute with the bishop and regional conference became public. In that announcement, the church said it is no longer part of the United Methodist Church, which the report describes as America’s second largest Protestant denomination. The same report says an overwhelming number of members voted to leave and that the church will change its name to Highland Park Methodist Church.
Sources (4):
- Here's what a Baptist sees in the HPUMC legal dispute (baptistnews.com)
- Texas megachurch may leave UMC amid ongoing legal battle with conference (christianpost.com)
- Embroiled in legal battle, Texas megachurch proposes leaving the UMC (christiancentury.org)
- Why is Highland Park Methodist Church leaving the United Methodist denomination? (dallasnews.com)