Historic Convent Closed Due to Damage Alleged from Pedestrianization Work Near Mormon Temple Site

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church) has closed the historic convent of Santa Catalina of Siena in Buenos Aires due to concerns over structural damage caused by pedestrianization work on Viamonte Street. The closure was announced by Father Gustavo Antico, who oversees the site, citing visible cracks in walls, ceilings, and columns within the convent. The damage, he stated, was attributed to the city’s construction efforts, which he said could have been avoided.

The LDS Church had recently received approval to build a temple adjacent to the convent, a decision that had already sparked controversy. The convent, a National Historical Monument, is located in the same block as the proposed temple, raising concerns about the impact of nearby construction. Father Antico emphasized that the LDS Church had previously raised alarms about the risks posed by such projects near the site.

The Buenos Aires government defended its actions, stating that manual work was used in the area to minimize damage to the historical structures. Officials noted that structural assessments are underway with experts to determine the exact cause of the cracks. They also suggested that some damage might have predated the pedestrianization work.

The convent’s authorities have requested that the city send a structural engineer to monitor the property and assess whether the temple construction can proceed safely. The closure of the convent has prompted calls for a thorough evaluation of the situation, with both parties acknowledging the need for careful handling of the historical site.

The controversy highlights the tension between urban development and the preservation of cultural heritage. The LDS Church’s temple project, which has drawn attention for its scale and location, now faces additional scrutiny as the convent’s condition remains a point of concern. The situation underscores the challenges of balancing modernization with the protection of historical landmarks.

Source: Read the original report (translated from Spanish)