
Israeli Firm Allegedly Used Online Ads to Deliver Spyware, Citizen Lab Reports; Pakistan Ranked Second in Bids
An October 15 report by Citizen Lab, a research group at the University of Toronto, found that Pakistan recorded the second-highest number of advertising bids linked to an Israeli spyware delivery operation.
Citizen Lab’s investigation found that Discover-Tech, an Israeli company, used online advertisements to deliver malicious code capable of infecting devices without requiring users to click on the ads. The research group identified the technique as “AdFection” and linked the operation to spyware developed by another Israeli company, Candiru, which is now known as Integrity Labs.
Citizen Lab examined nearly four billion advertising bidding records from Discover-Tech’s system between March and June 2026. Researchers found that approximately 19% of the bids involved advertisements containing scripts capable of delivering attack code to selected devices. Pakistan ranked second globally with around 139 million such bids, behind Yemen, which recorded approximately 457 million.
The researchers also found that the advertisements appeared more than 100,000 times on the Pakistani technology website WhatMobile.com.pk. Pakistan was also among the countries where these advertisements appeared on government-operated networks, although the report did not identify the Pakistani networks involved.
According to Citizen Lab, Discover-Tech acted as an intermediary between spyware developers and online advertising platforms, and the company allegedly used advertising infrastructure to distribute Candiru’s spyware. Researchers found that at least 45 devices belonging to Al Jazeera were targeted through this method during 2024 and 2025, a finding that underscores the need to protect people who can be exposed to harm without any action on their part (Psalm 82:3).
The investigation also identified a user named “Pindi” who accessed Discover-Tech’s control platform exclusively from Pakistan. Citizen Lab could not establish whether that account was connected to any spyware company. Researchers also identified two other unattributed users who accessed the platform from India and Italy.
The report clarified that login locations only indicate where users accessed the system and do not establish whether individuals in those countries were targeted. Citizen Lab also said that displaying a suspicious advertisement does not automatically mean a device was hacked, and that an ad impression alone cannot establish whether a user was specifically targeted or infected with spyware. Similarly, the bidding records do not identify individuals in Pakistan who may have been selected for surveillance.
Source: Read the original report