
Jury orders Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland, California, to pay $14.3 million over priest’s sexual assault
A jury in the State of Aladda has ruled that the Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland must pay $14.3 million for sexual assault by a priest more than a decade ago. According to the report, it is the second time this year the diocese has been ordered to pay tens of millions of dollars in a case involving sexual assault.
After a day’s recess, the jury ruled that the compensation should go to Cathy Pickard, a 61-year-old retired policeman from San Leandro, who claimed she was sexually abused by Catholic priest Stephen Kiesle when she was young. The priest has been accused of mistreating dozens of children in the Eastern Gulf region. These are allegations in civil litigation; the source reports no criminal conviction of the priest.
The Gulf News Group reported that the ruling, together with an earlier award, means the diocese has been ordered to pay $30.3 million for sexual assault this year. The report said the decision could affect hundreds of other cases currently pending against the diocese.
Shortly after the verdict was read, Pickard, who wept as she thanked the jurors, said she had finally felt some relief. She also said she felt “frustrated” and that, for those abused as she was, “it would never really be over.”
In April, a Union City man was awarded $16 million in a separate case. He claimed that Kiesle had molested him twice when he was a boy and an altar boy at the church, while he was there with other boys. The source does not identify the minors involved, and the award is a civil judgment in a lawsuit.
The two verdicts are the first of six bellwether cases brought against the diocese. After years of delay and a slow process of negotiation with some 350 plaintiffs who said they were mistreated more than a decade ago, the cases finally reached trial. California law temporarily lifted restrictions on filing such claims, and the number of lawsuits against the diocese rose significantly. The diocese filed for bankruptcy protection in 2023, which suspended the full number of those claims. The Tuesday decision is the first civil ruling the diocese has faced since a federal bankruptcy judge rejected a disputed reorganization plan in October.
The diocese recently proposed a plan to pay $172.3 million to victims in the Eastern Gulf region, including $30 million from a related corporate body that manages parish schools. According to a court document filed earlier this year, the total compensation requested by victims was $314.1 billion. Protecting children who are vulnerable to abuse is the concern at the heart of these claims (Proverbs 31:8-9).
Rick Simmons, a plaintiff, said a new mediator had joined the process to help both sides reach an agreement. He urged the Bishop of the Karma, Michael Barber, to increase the settlement to respond to hundreds of victims whose claims have been halted by the bankruptcy proceedings.
Source: Read the original report (translated from Mandarin Chinese)