
Op-ed disputes church leaders’ statement calling Christian Zionism a damaging ideology
An opinion piece published on Anglican Ink in February 2026 expresses dismay at a recent statement issued by the Patriarchs and heads of churches in Jerusalem. The statement described Christian Zionism as “a damaging ideology” and said it was favored by “those who push a political agenda which may harm the Christian presence in the Holy Land and the wider Middle East.” The writer, who identifies as an “evangelical Catholic,” says they share this dismay with other evangelical Catholic leaders. The disagreement over the statement is presented as a matter that can be voiced candidly and charitably among Christians (Ephesians 4:15).
The writer defines an “evangelical Catholic” as a Roman Catholic with evangelical convictions, namely a personal relationship with Jesus, confidence in the Gospel, and a desire to live out the fruit of the Holy Spirit. The author says that since the Second Vatican Council, millions of Roman Catholics have come into a personal relationship with Jesus through renewal movements within the Church. The piece cites an independent survey in Northern Ireland that found 38% of practicing Catholics also consider themselves evangelical.
The writer says they agree with a statement by the International Christian Embassy Jerusalem, published in The Jerusalem Post, which described a Zionism “purely biblical in origin, belief, scope and practice.” The writer also refers to a document titled “What is an Evangelical Catholic?”, which is described as signed by 60 evangelical Catholic leaders and carrying official Catholic Church endorsement. According to the piece, the document affirms commitment to the Jewish people and quotes Pope John Paul II on “the common roots linking Christianity and the Jewish people.”
The article points to several Catholic figures it says have affirmed a biblical view of Christian Zionism. It quotes Cardinal Raniero Cantalamessa, formerly the pope’s personal preacher, from his book The Mystery of Christmas, in which he writes that God gave Israel the land and that there is no mention of His taking it back. It also reports that in 2005, at Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Cardinal Schönborn of Austria said Christians should rejoice in the Jewish people’s return to Israel as a fulfilment of biblical prophecy, while warning Christians not to “usurp” Jewish uniqueness.
The writer identifies Towards Jerusalem Council 2 (TJC2), described as an international ministry working for healing between the churches and Israel, as sharing this view. One of its key leaders is named as Johannes Fichtenbauer of Vienna, a Catholic archdeacon. The piece summarizes his book The Mystery of the Olive Tree (New Life Publishing, 2019), which, according to the author, says the Jewish people will possess the land of Israel again as an independent state, will return from the four corners of the earth, and that Jerusalem will be freed from Gentile dominion before the end times.
The writer states that all Christian churches affirm the Scriptures as the word of God and claims there are 120 passages in the Tanach and the New Testament that speak of God bringing the Jewish people home, adding that this “is happening in our day.” The author argues that true Christian Zionism does not “mislead the public” but restates God’s promises concerning His relationship with the Jewish people. The piece also asks whether Cardinal Pizzaballa would consider requesting that his fellow Patriarchs affirm biblical Zionism and withdraw their joint statement.
On the statement’s assertion that the Patriarchs and heads of churches in Jerusalem “alone represent the churches” in the Holy Land, the writer says that they do not represent the 300 communities of Israeli followers of Jesus across Israel today.
Source: Read the original report