Bethlehem Pastor Munther Isaac Says West Bank Faces ‘Darkest Moment’ Amid Settlements, Roadblocks and Displacement

By Claudette Posted Nov 17, 2026 at 5:31 PM
Share:FacebookXEmail

Three Palestinian Christian activists, human rights lawyer Sahar Francis, social and political campaigner Rifat Kassis, and the Rev. Munther Isaac, pastor of Bethlehem’s Lutheran church, visited the Vatican on a Wednesday. In a long interview with Vatican News, they discussed the deteriorating situation in the West Bank, President Donald Trump’s proposal for the mass displacement of Gazans, and the importance of Pope Francis’ repeated calls for peace in the region.

Isaac, who is pastor of the Lutheran parishes in Bethlehem and Beit Sahour, said the West Bank is currently passing through one of its “darkest moments.” He explained that Israeli settlements and roadblocks are quickly making the area “uninhabitable,” cutting built-up areas off from each other and from surrounding villages. In effect, he said, the West Bank is becoming “a series of open-air prisons.” Around Bethlehem alone, he said, there are some 80 roadblocks, which often take six or seven hours at a time to cross.

Isaac also described economic devastation. Bethlehem used to rely heavily on religious tourism, which has now all but stopped, and as a result churches spend most of their time helping families without an income to survive, a picture of charity toward those in need (Matthew 25:35). The Rev. Isaac calculates that at least 100 of Bethlehem’s Christian families, already “a small community struggling to survive,” have left the city since the beginning of the war.

Perhaps the biggest threat, the pastor said, is the growing number of forced displacements. About 45,000 Palestinians have so far been displaced by Israeli military raids on refugee camps in the West Bank, and Isaac said he fears this devastation will spread. “We see what’s happening in Gaza,” he said, “and we ask: Will this be our fate too?”

The interview came shortly after Israel and Hamas carried out their sixth prisoner swap, which the report says prolonged the fragile ceasefire in Gaza. The Israeli hostages currently being released were seized in 2023 during Hamas’ October 7 attack on Israel. Many of the Palestinians they are being exchanged for, however, have been in prison for much longer. Francis, who is General Director of the Addameer Prisoner Support and Human Rights Association, explained that over the last few decades “hundreds of thousands” of Palestinians, including children, have been arbitrarily detained. She said that in Israeli prisons they can face “intimidation and humiliation, sexual harassment, beatings, and starvation,” along with other human rights abuses.

Francis also said scabies is rampant among Palestinian detainees. She said the contagious skin disease, caused by parasitic mites, has killed at least 60 prisoners held in Israeli jails over the past 15 months. She noted that while Israel is currently releasing large numbers of Palestinian prisoners for each Israeli hostage freed, it is also carrying out new mass arrests, including re-arresting prisoners released in previous exchanges. For Francis, the Israeli justice system is “not about implementing justice,” but is rather “a tool for the oppression and control of Palestinian society.”

The three activists are on a week-long tour of Italy organised by Kairos Palestine, a group that emerged from the 2009 Kairos Document written by a group of Christian leaders. Kassis, the General Secretary of Kairos Palestine, said the document was an attempt, “grounded in faith and our commitment to non-violence resistance,” to speak about the everyday difficulties faced by Palestinians. He stressed that the situation has worsened unimaginably since October 7, both in Gaza and the West Bank, and said Kairos is now working on a new document to complement the 2009 declaration. He warned that the situation could deteriorate further if Trump’s plan for the mass displacement of Gazans should take effect. In this regard, Kassis expressed approval of a recent statement from the Patriarchs and Heads of Churches in Jerusalem, which condemns the plans as “an injustice that strikes at the very heart of human dignity.”

Given the chaos that the forced displacement of Gaza’s 2 million inhabitants would entail, Kassis said, the proposal amounts not only to ethnic cleansing but also to a “call for a continuous war, not just in Palestine, but also in the entire region.” He also stressed the central importance of respect for international law, including the arrest warrants issued by the International Criminal Court against Hamas military commander Mohammed Deif and Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu.

The ICC was established in Rome, Kassis pointed out, and this is surely a reason for both Italy and the Holy See to be “doubly concerned” about the enforcement of its rulings.

Source: Read the original report

Kingdom News Location

Bethlehem, Area A, West Bank, Palestinian Territories

Open map

Claudette

Claudette is GracePress's virtual editorial byline for articles produced by Claude Haiku 5.5, a language model made by Anthropic and reached through Anthropic's API. She does not independently report, interview sources, or witness events. Working from linked source material, the GracePress News Ingest system uses Claude to rewrite articles within campaign-specific rules for factual attribution, careful treatment of allegations, Christian moral context, location extraction, and source disclosure. Every Claudette article identifies its underlying source and is published through GracePress's automated editorial workflow.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer