
Syro-Malabar Church Condemns Protests Against Archbishop Pamplany Over Phased Unified Holy Mass Rollout in Kochi, India
The dispute over how the Holy Mass should be celebrated in the Syro-Malabar Church, one of the Eastern Catholic churches in communion with Rome, dates to 2021. According to a report by Hindustan Times published that August, the church’s leadership issued a circular warning dissenting priests and laity that they faced excommunication if they celebrated the Holy Mass in any style other than the one prescribed by the church synod after July 3. The report said some faithful burned the circular in protest in many areas of Kerala. Five bishops, named in that report as Mar Ephrem Nariculam, Mar Jose Chittooparambil, Mar Jose Puthenveettil, Mar Kuriakose Bharanikulangara and Mar Sebastian Adayanthrath, questioned the hasty issuance of the circular without prior discussion at church forums. Their fellow bishops answered with a strongly worded reply calling the circular a mediaeval approach contrary to the spirit of the Second Vatican Council.
A separate report by NCR, also from August 2021, described the same dispute as a clash over liturgy. It said the synod, the church’s governing body, adopted a uniform mode for the Mass in August 2021. Under the new practice, priests face the altar during the Eucharistic prayer and face the congregation during the rest of the Mass, including the distribution of Communion. That report said most dioceses had embraced the change, while the Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese had resisted it. It stated that more than 400 of the archdiocese’s 470 priests and a majority of its 550,000 Catholics claim the traditional form of the Mass is in line with Vatican II. The reports differ on timing: the first places the synod’s prescribed style after July 3, while the second dates the synod’s adoption to August.
The dispute continued into 2025. ZENIT reported that the Major Archbishop, Raphael Thattil, announced an extraordinary synod on June 3, to convene on June 14. The gathering was to focus on implementing the Unified Holy Mass in the Archdiocese of Ernakulam-Angamaly. ZENIT described the dispute as stemming from the 2021 decision to introduce a uniform liturgy for the Syro-Malabar rite.
In December 2025, Outlook India reported that the Syro-Malabar Church had condemned protests against Archbishop Joseph Pamplany as unchristian and deeply deplorable. According to that report, the synod had permitted a phased rollout of the unified Holy Mass to preserve ecclesial communion amid local opposition. The Church reaffirmed its full support for Archbishop Pamplany, whose additional charge, the report said, had been assigned by the Holy Father and the Synod. The same report stated that protesters occupied St Mary’s, but the account was cut off at that point, and no further details of that occupation are available in the supplied material.
Sources (5):
- Syro-Malabar Church condemns protests against Archbishop Pamplany over unified Holy Mass row | Outlook India (outlookindia.com)
- Dissenting priests in Syro-Malabar Church protest Pope Francis’ Christmas deadline – EWTN Vatican (ewtnvatican.com)
- Caught between altar and the masses: Divisions emerge in the Syro-Malabar Church over holy mass format (hindustantimes.com)
- Syro-Malabar Church convenes extraordinary synod to resolve liturgical dispute – ZENIT – English (zenit.org)
- Syro-Malabar Catholics in India clash over liturgical dispute (ncronline.org)
Kingdom News Location
St.Thomas Church (Syrian rite), Archdiocese of Ernakulam-Angamaly, Church Landind Road, Varappuzha, Paravur, Ernakulam, Kerala, 683517, India
Open map