
Trinity Lutheran School in Menasha, Wisconsin, to Close at End of Semester
Trinity Lutheran School in Menasha, Wisconsin, will close at the end of the semester, according to NBC 26. Parents said the announcement was unexpected. They had received a letter asking them to attend a Tuesday meeting, where the closure was announced. Families have since criticized the timing of the closure and what they describe as a lack of transparency from the school online. One parent, Nikki Ann, wrote an open letter to the school objecting to the closure in the middle of the school year.
NBC 26 contacted Trinity Lutheran Church and School for comment, but officials declined to comment.
WBAY reported that the church’s congregation voted to close the school after the fall semester. The church’s president, Dave Collingwood, said the official decision came this week, after the school’s finances had been under review for about two years. The church attributes its funding problems to declining enrollment, rising operating costs and deferred building maintenance. Collingwood said these factors made the school’s current model unsustainable.
WBAY reported figures for the 2025-26 school year: the school’s expenses reached about $691,000, and its income was $145,000. Operating the school cost the church about $546,000 in that one year. Collingwood said the financial data was presented at a June budget meeting, and that the congregation still chose to welcome students back that fall. The two reports differ on how the decision was communicated. Parents described the announcement as unexpected, while the church’s account places the financial data before the congregation months earlier, at the June meeting. Accountability for how those finances were shared with families, as Proverbs 11:1 calls for honest dealing, remains a point of dispute in the parents’ criticism.
Collingwood said that operating the school for a full year would put the whole church at risk of going under. He said the church will work with families to find alternate schooling options for the spring semester.
Sources (2):