
Tustin, California, City Council votes to relocate homeless shelter from site near elementary school
The Tustin City Council voted unanimously Tuesday night, Dec. 18, to relocate a temporary homeless shelter that has not yet opened. The council moved the project away from its proposed site near an elementary school and chose the former U.S. Army Reserve site at 2345 Barranca Parkway, at the District at Tustin Legacy shopping center.
The meeting was low-key compared with earlier sessions, in which parents passionately objected to the original location. The council had also considered a vacant parcel on the southeast corner of Armstrong and Warner avenues as an alternative.
Both sites had drawbacks. The Barranca address sits directly across the street from Irvine, and city officials have expressed concern that Irvine might file a lawsuit, which could embroil the locale in lengthy litigation. The Armstrong and Warner site is not convenient to bus lines, stores and other amenities that shelter residents need, a matter of hospitality toward people who depend on those services (Matthew 25:35). Trailer homes and some infrastructure would also have to be brought in there. Preparing that vacant lot would cost around $3 million, about $1.3 million more than the Army Reserve building.
The city considered readying both locations in case the preferred one fell through, but council members decided against spending extra money simply as a precaution. “If it turns out that it is legally challenged, staff should come back with another recommendation, but we should not be funding both,” said Councilman Allan Bernstein.
The city faces a tight timeline. In August, a judge determined that cities and the County of Orange must provide housing for 60 percent of their total homeless counts, based on 2017 statistics. Entities that fail to meet a February deadline cannot enforce anti-camping ordinances until they offer homeless people an alternative to the streets. Tustin must produce at least 42 beds. The city had believed it found a solution when the Christian-oriented Orange County Rescue Mission agreed to add 50 beds, but officials had to return to square one in September, when the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a city cannot “coerce an individual to attend religion-based treatment programs.”
City Manager Jeff Parker said at Tuesday’s meeting that bordering cities, including Santa Ana, have begun opening shelters under the judge’s order, which gives them the green light to cite or arrest people sleeping on public property. He said that some homeless people who decline to stay in shelters have drifted into Tustin.
On Oct. 25, the city announced it would place a temporary shelter next door to Heritage Elementary School at The Legacy for about two years, until it could find a more suitable location. Parents claimed the shelter would pose a risk to children. Residents quickly organized protests at a rally, a town hall and city council meetings. At first, all five council members held to their unanimous decision to place the shelter in the vacant building originally earmarked for a police station.
The opposition grew so contentious that parents began a recall effort against Bernstein, a vocal proponent of the disputed site. Two new council members, who took their seats in early December, sided with residents in opposing the site near Heritage. At a special council meeting Dec. 6, Parker told the packed chambers that the city would cease renovations at the site while officials considered other options.
After Tuesday’s vote, Heritage parent Jeff Lawrence, the lead organizer of the protest, said residents were “ecstatic” about the change. “To think that just five short weeks ago there were five votes for the site (near the school), it’s just incredible that we accomplished a complete turnaround in such a short period of time,” he said. Bernstein closed his remarks after the vote by noting that council members “heard the people speak.”
Source: Read the original report