United Methodist Churches Approve Disaffiliation, Anticipating Denomination’s Liberalization on LGBTQ Issues

The United Methodist Church is experiencing a significant wave of disaffiliation as congregations seek to distance themselves from what they perceive as the denomination’s shifting theological direction. As of recent approvals, 1,314 churches have officially left the denomination, with hundreds more in the process of voting to exit. This trend is expected to accelerate, with at least 3,000 and possibly 5,000 congregations disaffiliating by the end of the year. These departures are largely driven by conservative churches anticipating the denomination’s liberalization on LGBTQ issues, particularly as the 2024 General Conference approaches.

The impact of this exodus is expected to be substantial. Denominational agencies are preparing for a 38% reduction in funding for the period 2025-2028, which could result in a membership loss of approximately 2.3 million from the nearly 6.3 million U.S. members recorded in 2020. This decline underscores the growing divide within the denomination and the challenges it faces in maintaining its institutional structure and financial stability.

Many of the exiting churches are anticipated to join the Global Methodist Church, a new conservative denomination formed to provide an alternative for those seeking a more traditional theological stance. However, not all departing congregations are aligning with this new entity. Some, like White’s Chapel United Methodist Church in Dallas, are choosing a different path. With nearly 6,000 weekly worshippers, White’s Chapel recently voted overwhelmingly to leave the UMC, surprising many due to its size and influence.

White’s Chapel has opted to form what it calls a “Methodist Collegiate College,” aiming to create a new model of church connectionalism. This initiative seeks to retain Wesleyan theology and Methodist traditions while avoiding denominational control over property, clergy appointments, and ordination processes. The congregation’s goal is to prioritize “people over polity,” emphasizing shared ministry and practical governance over centralized authority.

This movement reflects a broader trend in American Christianity toward post-denominationalism, where congregations are increasingly seeking autonomy and rejecting the bureaucratic structures of traditional denominations. The Global Methodist Church, while conservative, also embodies this spirit by allowing congregations greater control over their resources and leadership. This shift highlights a growing desire among many Christians to define their faith practices independently of institutional frameworks.

The situation presents a complex landscape for the United Methodist Church, as it grapples with internal divisions and the consequences of its evolving policies. As congregations continue to leave, the denomination must navigate the challenges of maintaining its identity and relevance in a rapidly changing religious environment. The future of United Methodism remains uncertain, with the potential for significant transformation in its structure and mission.

Source: Read the original report