
Utah Supreme Court Hears Challenge to Zoning for LDS Heber Valley Temple
The Utah Supreme Court has taken up a dispute between a Heber neighborhood and Wasatch County over a planned temple for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
The court heard arguments Friday in a legal challenge to a zoning change that allowed the faith’s Heber Valley Temple to be built near the residents’ homes. Bruce Van Dusen, one of the plaintiffs, said he and his neighbors bought homes in an area with longstanding zoning that applied to many blocks. He said an 18-acre plot in the middle of that neighborhood was “magically determined to not have to obey any of the rules of the entire neighborhood.”
The residents sued after Wasatch County allowed the temple to proceed even though it does not match other zoning restrictions in the area. They have said they expect increased traffic and bright lights from the temple, among other effects. A lower-court judge sided with the county, and the neighbors appealed.
At the Supreme Court, the justices focused on whether Utah law allows the residents to challenge the decision under land-use laws and whether they have standing to bring the lawsuit. Lawyers for Wasatch County and the church argued that they do not. David Jordan, an attorney for the church, cited a statute presuming that a properly enacted land-use regulation is valid. Robert Mansfield, the neighbors’ attorney, responded that the county’s position was that its decision could not be reviewed, which he said was “just not proper.”
Outside the courtroom, Jordan said county councils and other political bodies that approve such projects are accountable to their constituents and “were well within their discretion to approve the plan for the temple.” Jonathan Woodard, an attorney for Wasatch County, noted that the legislature made “a lot of changes last year.” Justice Paige Petersen remarked that comparing the different versions made the job challenging, which drew some laughter in the courtroom.
FOX 13 News observed work already underway on the temple grounds. The Utah Supreme Court had previously allowed some work to proceed while the case was litigated. Van Dusen told reporters that if the temple “adhered to the zoning regulation that every other building and every other church had adhered to, we wouldn’t be here.” He added, “They have a right to build. It’s their property. They just don’t have a right to invent rules.”
Associate Chief Justice Jill Pohlman and Justice Jay Jorgensen have recused themselves from the case. Justice Jorgensen was appointed to the court by Governor Spencer Cox and had previously served as a lawyer for the church. Recusal means the justices will not hear arguments or have any input on the case.
Source: Read the original report