
Youth pastor in Duncan, Oklahoma, faces two felony child sexual abuse charges
Court documents filed Oct. 6 in Stephens County charge Andrew Paul Benton, 27, with two felony counts of child sexual abuse, each classified as a Class A3 felony. Benton, an Oklahoma youth pastor, has been accused of sexually abusing teenage girls under his care. The charging document alleges that he abused one girl who was part of his church’s youth group between March 15, 2025, and Feb. 21, 2026. The second count alleges abuse of a girl who was his foster child between July 2024 and March 18, 2026.
Benton served as president of the Assembly of Our Lord Jesus Christ, or ALJC, and as youth pastor at Grace Chapel Pentecostal Church in Duncan, about 80 miles south of Oklahoma City. The affidavit was prepared by Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation Special Agent Lindsey Adamson. It identifies the church’s head pastor as Ed Jackson, Benton’s father-in-law.
The two-count charging document alleges that Benton “willfully and maliciously” engaged in sexual conduct with a minor and touched another minor while serving as her foster parent. These are allegations. The separate arrest warrant affidavit describes additional allegations involving multiple girls and seeks Benton’s arrest on suspicion of one count of first-degree rape, three counts of second-degree rape, three counts of sexual battery, destruction of evidence, using computers to violate Oklahoma statutes, and engaging in a pattern of criminal offenses. The affidavit’s allegations are not the same as the two charges listed in the October filing.
Adamson wrote that the investigation began after Duncan police requested state assistance on March 4. She cautioned that “each and every fact known is not included in this affidavit, just enough to establish probable cause.” According to the affidavit, one girl told investigators that Benton began contacting her on Snapchat in February 2025 and that he later abused her at a church-related gathering in Colbert, Oklahoma, and during a visit to the Benton home in August 2025. Another girl, who had lived with Benton and his wife since 2024, told investigators about unwanted touching in the home. She said that after she announced in February 2026 that she was moving out, Benton asked her to stay and told her he would not touch her again. The affidavit alleges that further touching occurred days later.
The affidavit also describes complaints made to church leadership before the investigation. A former youth group member told investigators that she and her father had complained to Jackson about Benton’s conduct. According to the affidavit, Jackson responded with something like, “We all need to work on ourselves,” and took no action. The girl’s mother, Rhonda Snider, told investigators that she also raised the matter with Jackson, “but nothing was done to ANDREW,” according to the affidavit. Church leadership’s handling of these complaints is described in the affidavit; the document does not establish any finding about that handling beyond the statements it records. Responsibility placed on those who hold authority in a church (Luke 12:48).
Investigators obtained a warrant to examine Benton’s phone. Adamson reported finding thousands of messages between Benton and one of the girls, including a message in which he wrote, “You’re my everything, you make my life better, I love you.” The affidavit also says investigators found searches about deleting social media accounts and about emergency protective orders and firearms.
On March 24, Duncan police arrested Benton for allegedly violating a protective order involving one of the girls. The affidavit further alleges that Benton asked his wife to remotely lock his phone and later told her to retrieve information from his devices. The October charging papers do not establish the current status of the foster child.
Each of the two filed charges carries a potential sentence of up to life imprisonment. The filing also specifies a minimum fine of $500 and a requirement that any prison sentence be served at least 85 percent of its length.
Source: Read the original report