
ACLU Report Details Unsanitary Conditions and Staff Misconduct at Orange County Homeless Shelters
The American Civil Liberties Union has released a report stating that homeless people living at County-run shelters in Orange County face unsafe and unsanitary conditions, abusive staff misconduct, and retaliation for speaking up about those problems. The report was released on a Thursday and was authored by ACLU policy analyst Eve Garrow.
Garrow said that emergency shelters often have problems of this kind, but added, “I have to say, that I have never seen anything as egregious as I’ve seen in these shelters in Orange County.”
The ACLU effort was compiled over the past year and analyzed three County-run shelters: the Courtyard homeless shelter at an abandoned bus terminal in Downtown Santa Ana; Bridges at Kraemer Place in Anaheim, next to the 91 freeway; and SAFEPlace, a women’s shelter in Downtown Santa Ana. Describing the Courtyard, Garrow said it is an open-air bus terminal “not meant for habitation,” with no temperature controls, leaving people in freezing conditions in winter and dangerously hot conditions in summer. She also cited flooding problems with portable toilets and contamination by raw sewage.
A County statement provided by spokeswoman Molly Nichelson said the County of Orange is committed to keeping its emergency shelters safe for all clients. The statement said each shelter has its own provider and complaint process, and that the County works to ensure valid complaints are addressed in a timely fashion. It said the County will review the report and respond to it accordingly.
The report also alleges that shelter staff retaliate against homeless people who speak up about conditions. According to the report, people at the Courtyard, which has a maximum capacity of about 425, who voice concerns are often kicked out. Former resident David Adams, recalling his time there, is quoted in the report: “They’ll roll you up for anything. Questioning a staff or disagreeing with an order, having food next to your bed, laying down during the day.” Protecting people who have little power to defend themselves is a matter of justice (Psalm 82:3).
The report includes an undated photograph of a sign at SAFEPlace that lays out complaint policies for residents. The sign reads, in part: “Guests who have an issue with a staff member must use the SAFEPlace grievance process. If the guest does not choose to use this process and grievances are made public or constant [an] exit date will be assigned.” The report says the sign was allegedly posted at the women’s shelter. Garrow said shelters use eviction and the threat of eviction “as a way to discipline and manage these large populations of residents,” and that this threat silences residents and often results in retaliation and eviction when they speak out.
The report was issued as the County and five South County cities were ordered to appear in federal court in less than three weeks. U.S. District Judge David O. Carter, who is overseeing lawsuits against the County and the South County cities, also asked city managers, mayors, and police chiefs from all 34 Orange County cities to appear at the April 2 court hearing. The lawsuits, filed by attorneys Brooke Weitzman and Carol Sobel, focus on shelter bed shortages and police enforcement of anti-camping laws, which the lawyers contend criminalize homelessness. The original lawsuit was filed in January 2018 over the eviction of roughly 1,000 homeless people from the Santa Ana Riverbed homeless camp. People from the riverbed moved to the streets, where, the source reports, citations and arrests for camping and loitering awaited them because they had nowhere to go.
Source: Read the original report