
Catholic Herald Columnist Asks What Happens if a Pope Cannot Govern, Citing Leo XIV’s Surgery
Columnist Luke Collins raised the question of what happens when a pope can no longer exercise his authority in a piece published on November 6 in The Catholic Herald, titled “What happens if a pope becomes incapacitated?” The column is an opinion piece and not a report on the Pontiff’s health. Collins writes that Pope Leo XIV’s surgery has brought the issue back to the table: what occurs in the Church when a pope is no longer able to govern.
According to Collins, the Pope’s recovery “has brought relief,” but the operation “raises an unresolved question” about the Church’s response in such a case. He does not confine himself to the present situation. To introduce the matter, he turns to history. Collins recalls that in 1811, when King George III of England was incapacitated by illness, the British Parliament appointed his son as regent. In the same year, Pope Pius VII was being held captive by Napoleon, who had abducted him from the Quirinal two years earlier. Unlike the British monarchy, Collins writes, “the Catholic Church had no prince regent.”
Pius VII, the columnist adds, remained pope during his captivity. He communicated with the outside world through letters smuggled out, resisted Napoleon’s attempts to bring the Church under his control, and returned to Rome in 1814. Collins uses the example to illustrate his point that the government of the Church lacks a mechanism to replace a pope who is incapacitated. Leadership carries heavy responsibility, a point the historical example brings out (Luke 12:48).
Leo XIV underwent surgery on October 13 at the Policlinico Gemelli in Rome. Two weeks later, the Holy See confirmed that the apostolic journey to Uruguay, Argentina, and Peru, scheduled for November 6–17, would proceed. The confirmation followed medical checks that raised no objections to the trip, as reported by InfoVaticana.
The Pope departed for Montevideo this Friday, so the column appeared while the Pontiff had already resumed his international schedule. Collins’s reflection therefore does not refer to a current state of incapacity. It concerns the gap that, in his view, a pope’s illness exposes and that Church law has not resolved.
Source: Read the original report