Covenant Christian Academy ex-director accused of stealing school funds

Tyler McGatha, 45, former director of Covenant Christian Academy in Greer, has been arrested and charged with breach of trust exceeding $10,000. The Greenville County Sheriff’s Office announced the charges following an investigation into alleged financial misconduct at the school. The probe began in November 2025 after church leadership reported concerns that McGatha may have taken money from the church in exchange for guaranteeing enrollment placements.

Authorities revealed that McGatha manipulated payroll records, crediting at least two part-time employees with more hours than they worked, leading to overpayment from school funds. Investigators also found that McGatha accepted cash payments from new enrollees for placement guarantees and allegedly used the money for personal purposes rather than depositing it with the organization. Additionally, McGatha used the church’s credit card for personal purchases.

McGatha was charged Tuesday and released after posting a $10,000 bond. Covenant Church and Covenant Christian Academy issued a statement expressing heartbreak over the breach of financial trust. They emphasized their commitment to integrity and accountability while acknowledging the ongoing legal process. The statement noted the community’s support and expressed gratitude for prayers and encouragement during this difficult time.

The church leadership took action to review the financial operations, sought professional assistance for a thorough investigation, and turned the findings over to law enforcement. They remain focused on the mission of the church and school, while the matter proceeds through the legal system. The case highlights the importance of transparency and stewardship in financial matters, as Proverbs 31:8-9 reminds us to speak up for those who cannot speak for themselves.

This incident underscores the need for vigilance in safeguarding resources entrusted to those in leadership. As Micah 6:8 teaches, we are called to act justly, love mercy, and walk humbly with God. The community continues to pray for justice, accountability, and restoration in the wake of these allegations.

Source: Read the original report