
George Fox University in Newberg, Oregon, Wins Title IX Religious Exemption in Dispute Over Trans Student’s Campus Housing
George Fox University, a Quaker school in Newberg, Oregon, has refused campus housing to Jayce M., a transgender student who has lived as a man socially for several years. After the university denied Jayce’s repeated appeals for housing, Jayce’s attorney filed a Title IX discrimination complaint with the U.S. Department of Education, according to a report by PQ Monthly. That week, the department granted the school a religious exemption from the Title IX requirement. Jayce and his attorney said they were not aware that George Fox had applied for the exemption.
Jayce’s attorney, Paul Southwick, said he had not received information about the nature of the request or the exemption despite repeated requests. He said a department representative told him after receiving the department’s letter that he was “not authorized” to discuss the exemption. Southwick said the department normally decides within 30 days whether to investigate a complaint, but in this case the family waited about 90 days without being told the reason. He said the family will appeal the department’s ruling.
Jayce’s mother, Janice, has started a Change.org petition in support of her child’s case. She wrote that she wants Jayce “to be safe and to feel included in the campus community” and to be allowed to live in on-campus housing with his male friends, noting that those friends have no problem sharing a dorm with him. According to the source, Jayce says he has received support and built community at the school, including from friends, faculty members and students in an unofficial LGBT and allies club called Common Ground. He told PQ in April that he is not the only transgender student on campus.
The university has announced a plan to change its policy so that all dorm placements will be based on a student’s “biological sex at birth.” The source reports that the administration appears to be the source of the barriers to Jayce’s full inclusion. Without seeing the ruling, the source says, it is not clear what the basis of the university’s request was.
The source describes George Fox as belonging to an Evangelical branch of Quakerism that adopts more conservative Evangelical Christian beliefs than many Quaker communities. It also states that Quakers commonly regard community, equality and honesty as key parts of spiritual practice, and that the testimony of integrity calls Friends to deal honestly with others in word and deed. Darleen Ortega, a Quaker, George Fox alumna and judge on the Oregon Court of Appeals, said the school has been opaque in its handling of the case. The source’s author, a Presbyterian pastor, wrote that the university’s position is not supported by scripture or Friends theology, and argued that the case calls for honest dealing with Jayce, a point that ties to the call to speak the truth (Ephesians 4:15).
The source notes that religious exemptions of this kind have become more common, pointing to a recent Hobby Lobby ruling as part of the same trend. With the new school year a few weeks away, Jayce and his supporters said they will continue to pursue his right to campus housing.
Source: Read the original report