
Quaker parent describes school’s response to 10-year-old’s objection to army trip
A Quaker parent and school governor has written an account of a painful dispute with their 10-year-old daughter’s primary school over a class visit to a local army headquarters. The visit was planned in the run-up to the SATs tests, when parents were asked to consent to the trip.
The daughter had grown up attending Quaker Meeting and wears a white poppy each year. She was concerned about the trip, and after the family discussed it and watched Quaker Peace & Social Witness’s film *The Unseen March*, she decided she had a conscientious objection and did not want to go. Her parent, who was worried that she would miss a shared class experience, wrote to the school stating that the objection was made on grounds of conscience and asking for alternative activities. The letter was handed in at the head’s office and was intended to open a dialogue.
As the trip drew closer, the parent realised the letter had not been passed to the child’s teacher and that no dialogue was taking place. The daughter was encouraged to take part, which the parent said put her in a very difficult position. On the day of the trip she spent the time helping a younger class, which she said she enjoyed, but she later heard from friends about an instructor dismantling a gun and describing it as “just like any other machine.” The parent wrote to the school again, raising concern about children aged 8 to 10 being presented with this view of guns (Proverbs 18:17).
According to the parent, the teacher did not share these concerns and regarded the trip as a healthy activity because it included an assault course. The parent says they were asked why no other parents had objected and were asked to leave the matter alone, and wrote that they felt effectively silenced. The parent also said that, without raising concerns, their daughter’s conscientious objection would not have been respected, and that an uncritical introduction to weapons and the Armed Forces is, for some children and adults, deeply problematic.
The parent describes the concerns as moral and religious as well as educational. They argue that the purpose of education, including encouraging each child’s spirit of enquiry and weighing different points of view and evidence, is undermined by the promotion of the armed forces in schools. The parent said they had spoken to teachers in other areas, such as London, who said such visits would not be tolerated, partly because some pupils come from conflict areas. In their own economically deprived area, the parent said, the visit was presented as a positive option to be accepted without question. The parent cited Ben Griffin of Veterans for Peace UK, who appears in *The Unseen March*, on the place of questioning in military ethos. The parent, whose own father served in the armed forces and described them as the “poor man’s University,” said they were shocked that the Armed Forces were allowed to target areas of deprivation in this way.
The parent says the family has received strong support from their local Quaker meeting and wants other parents facing similar situations to know they are not alone. They point to resources from Quaker Peace & Social Witness (QPSW) and to the organisation Forces Watch for challenging Government policy to increase the military presence in schools. The parent reports that Quakers across the country are beginning to act on militarisation by writing to their MPs and the local press. In the parent’s view, the policy of promoting military involvement in education has lacked public scrutiny, raises serious religious, ethical and educational questions, and requires proper debate.
Source: Read the original report