Hutterite leaders demand apology for National Geographic show’s portrayal of their community

Leaders of a Hutterite colony in central Montana have called for an apology from the National Geographic Society, claiming that a television show about their community misrepresented their way of life and harmed their reputation. The show, titled *American Colony: Meet the Hutterites*, aired earlier this year and has sparked controversy within the Hutterite community.

National Geographic Channel CEO David Lyle has stated that an apology is unnecessary, asserting the show provided a fair and accurate portrayal of Hutterite life. However, Hutterite leaders argue that the production transformed what was intended to be a documentary into a reality TV show that fostered internal discord. They accuse the producers of inventing situations and directing participants on what to say and do during filming.

King Ranch Colony minister John Hofer, who wrote a letter to National Geographic Society chairman John Fahey, described the show as a betrayal. He said the producers encouraged generational conflict and misrepresented the Hutterites’ values. Hofer expressed concern that the show’s portrayal has led to a public humiliation of the community and damaged their reputation globally.

Hutterites, a Protestant group of German descent, live in communal colonies across the western United States and Canada. Their lifestyle, while sharing similarities with that of the Amish and Mennonites, includes the use of modern technology in agricultural practices. The show focused on the King Ranch colony, highlighting themes such as education, the role of women, and the challenges of adapting to modern life.

Producer Jeff Collins noted that the negative reaction to the show may have originated from Hutterite elders in Canada, who are displeased with the portrayal of certain aspects of Hutterite life. While many in the King Ranch colony are proud of the show, Collins believes they are now under pressure to protest its content.

The situation reflects the tension between cultural preservation and public exposure, a theme that resonates with the Hutterites’ commitment to maintaining their traditions while navigating the complexities of modernity. The community’s response underscores the delicate balance between sharing their story and protecting their way of life.