
Jordan’s Refusal to Admit Palestinians Unlikely to Change, Commentary Says
In a commentary published November 21, 2023, by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Marwan Muasher, Carnegie’s vice president for studies and a former foreign minister of Jordan, wrote that Israel’s bombardment of Gaza, the high number of Palestinian civilians killed, and discussion of opening safe passages from Gaza to Egypt had revived a long-standing Jordanian fear. Jordan worries that Israel might create or use wartime conditions to push large numbers of Palestinians from Gaza into Egypt and from the West Bank into Jordan.
Muasher wrote that former Israeli prime minister Ariel Sharon, among other Israeli politicians, had raised the idea of Jordan serving as an alternative home for Palestinians, claiming that many Jordanians are of Palestinian origin. When Jordan and Israel signed a peace treaty in 1994, Jordan insisted on a clause against mass transfer. Muasher quoted Article 2.6 of the treaty, which states that “within their control, involuntary movements of persons in such a way as to adversely prejudice the security of either Party should not be permitted.” That safeguard, a protection for people with little power over their own movement, reflects Jordan’s long-held concern (Proverbs 31:8-9).
Muasher wrote that Sharon’s views are now “front and center” in Israel’s current government coalition, which he said includes two ministers who believe the West Bank and Gaza belong to Israel and that Palestinians living there have no right to them. He wrote that for the past month, Jordan and Egypt had repeatedly declared that their borders would not be opened to receive any Palestinians. He described this as a countermove intended to prevent Israel from emptying the West Bank and Gaza of Palestinians, not a refusal of humanitarian aid to Palestinians under attack.
Muasher argued that Jordan’s position follows from Israel’s stated positions. In his account, Israeli government statements have made clear that Israel does not intend to end the occupation or allow a viable Palestinian state based on the 1967 border. He wrote that the apparent Israeli position leaves Palestinians with more than self-rule but less than a state, in a “Bantustan”-like arrangement surrounded by Israel. He said former U.S. president Donald Trump’s “deal of the century” laid out such a plan and was widely suspected of being a mere articulation of the Israeli position. He also cited demographic figures, reporting 7.4 million Palestinians and 7.2 million Israelis in areas under Israel’s control, and said Palestinian birth rates were higher than Israeli ones.
Muasher cited the designation of “apartheid-like” legal structures by B’Tselem, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, and others. He wrote that Israel’s Palestinian citizens, who make up 21 percent of the population, were legally deemed second-class citizens after a 2018 law declared Israel a nation-state for the Jewish people. He also said Palestinians under occupation are subject to a separate legal system from Jewish settlers in the West Bank and Jerusalem. He reported that the commentary’s view of the West Bank was shaped by settler raids on Palestinian villages, which he said occur daily with the backing of the Israeli army. He wrote that the events “create the impression” that radicals in the Israeli government see the Gaza war as an opportunity for ethnic cleansing in the West Bank.
Muasher also described history and identity as factors. He wrote that in 1948, 750,000 Palestinians left or were expelled from the new state of Israel, and that UN Resolution 194 affirmed refugees’ right to return, though he wrote that no Palestinian had been officially permitted to do so. He said that after the 1948 war, Jordan’s population roughly tripled, and that Palestinian refugees were given Jordanian citizenship. He wrote that the Jordanian establishment never fully accepted this change and that the resolve not to admit more Palestinians comes from both that concern about identity and an official position against a Palestinian state outside Palestinian territory. He noted that Jordan has accepted non-Palestinian refugees since 1990, but said Palestinian refugees do not fit the same categories.
Muasher concluded that the border closure, which he acknowledged may appear insensitive to Palestinian suffering, enjoys wide domestic and Arab support, and that it is viewed in the region as an attempt to block Israel’s desire to remove its Palestinian population. He wrote that Palestinians themselves support the position, and that the redline is unlikely to change even if the war with Hamas spreads.
Source: Read the original report