
Mormon Church Rejected Polygamy in 1890, but Fundamentalist Communities Continue the Practice
The Conversation article opens with recent news about polygamy in Utah, including the arrest of polygamist leader Lyle Jeffs, evictions of polygamist families, and new studies on genetic disorders in small ultra-orthodox or “fundamentalist” Mormon communities in rural Utah. The author writes that this attention is likely to make most nonfundamentalist Mormons uncomfortable. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS), the mainstream Mormon church with 15 million members worldwide, publicly rejected polygamy in 1890. The author, a scholar of Mormonism and gender who identifies as a Mormon, says mainstream members still encounter stereotypes about the practice.
The article traces the teaching to Joseph Smith, who founded the Mormon movement in 1830. According to the piece, Smith developed the belief that families could be together in heaven if they underwent religious rites called “sealings” in temples, which any faithful member approved by church leaders could perform. After a vision of his brother Alvin in 1836, Smith taught that a righteous man could help numerous women and children reach heaven through plural marriage, a view the article says was established as doctrine in 1843.
Rumors that a small group of LDS leaders practiced polygamy led to mob violence against early Mormon settlements in Illinois and Missouri, the article reports. Smith counseled men to be “crafty” in their practice, which scholars have interpreted to mean alert, wise and resourceful. After Smith was murdered in 1845, Mormons migrated to Utah Territory in 1847. Under Brigham Young, the church announced plural marriage as an official practice in 1852. The article states that by the 1880s an estimated 20 to 30 percent of Mormon families practiced polygamy.
Opposition grew after the U.S. Civil War. The Supreme Court, in Reynolds v. United States (1878), described polygamy as “odious,” and Congress passed the Edmunds-Tucker Act in 1887. That law authorized the seizure of LDS Church assets and made polygamy a federal offense. The article says entire families went “underground” to avoid imprisonment, and that mobs in the American South attacked Mormon missionaries in the 1880s. Mormon men were also stereotyped as fanatics who exploited converts, a portrayal the article presents as part of the period’s public debate.
Under this pressure, LDS Church President Wilford W. Woodruff announced in 1890 that the church would no longer sanction plural marriages in accordance with U.S. law. The article notes that such marriages continued among Mormons in Mexico, some of whom had moved there from Utah to continue the practice, and among rogue LDS leaders through the 1920s. The author also notes that the church’s acceptance of the rule did not end the practice’s history of tension within the faith, a point the article connects to the church’s broader struggle over what the practice meant for Mormon men. Honest accounting of this record, the article suggests, is part of understanding it, as with the need to speak the truth in love (Ephesians 4:15).
In the 1930s, seven leading Mormon polygamists formed a loose confederation of fundamentalist Mormons to continue the practice, the article reports. Several were excommunicated from the mainstream LDS Church. These fundamentalist groups formed close-knit communities across the West, from Canada to Mexico, that the article says survive today. Fundamentalist Mormons broke from the LDS Church in the early 20th century to continue open polygamy, while members who remained in the church moved toward mainstream American norms and assimilation.
The article concludes that mainstream Mormons developed new norms of Mormon manhood that seemed safer to the American public.
Source: Read the original report