
Training Church Elders from Within: A Six-Step Plan for Pastors
The post, written by Chase Krug, starts from a common question: what should a pastor do when a congregation has no one who meets the New Testament qualifications for elders? The author’s answer is to train them. He describes the elder as an office rather than a life stage, pointing to the pastoral role of shepherding the flock and the character qualities listed in 1 Timothy and Titus. He offers six steps as a practical starting point that pastors can adapt to their own church’s needs and setting.
The first step is to identify character before competence. Competence can be developed to a degree, but godliness must be present from the start, and giftedness should never outweigh it. The author suggests looking first among people already serving in the church. Once potential candidates are found, leaders should talk with them about the training and its time commitment, expect some reluctance, and invite them to prayer and further reflection. He stresses including wives in the discernment process, since a supportive spouse matters for long-term ministry.
Next, candidates complete a detailed onboarding questionnaire covering doctrine, ethics, personal life, and skills. The post says that honest answers are encouraged, and that admitting a gap in knowledge or a past failure is not automatically disqualifying. After review and follow-up, the first year of formal training focuses on theology, using a systematic theology text, monthly discussion meals, and varied assignments such as videos and gospel conversations. Later training turns to practical shepherding topics and gives candidates supervised experience in public ministry. The author closes by warning against advancing candidates who are not able to teach, since this would both ignore Scripture and harm the church over time.
Source: Read the original report