
Vatican Court Ruling Clears Way for Msgr Antony Narikulam to Return as Ernakulam Basilica Vicar
Monsignor Antony Narikulam is set to return as Vicar of St. Mary’s Cathedral Basilica, Ernakulam, following a ruling by the Apostolic Signatura, the supreme judicial authority of the Catholic Church. According to a circular issued by the Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocesan Chancery on November 10, he will formally assume charge on November 12.
The decision comes in a long-running dispute in the Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese over disciplinary measures taken against priests who opposed the mandatory implementation of the Syro-Malabar Church’s uniform mode of celebrating the Holy Qurbana. Under that arrangement, approved by the Syro-Malabar Synod in 2021, the priest faces the congregation during the Liturgy of the Word and turns towards the altar during the Eucharistic Prayer. A substantial section of priests and faithful in the archdiocese opposed the compulsory implementation and maintained their preference for celebrating the Eucharist facing the congregation throughout.
Archbishop Andrews Thazhath, then Apostolic Administrator of the archdiocese, had warned the Basilica’s parish council on June 24, 2023, of disciplinary action for refusing to comply with the Synod’s directives. On July 4, 2023, he ordered Msgr Narikulam’s removal from the Basilica, relieving him of his responsibilities as vicar and appointing him Vicar of St Mary’s Forane Church, Moozhikulam, with immediate effect. The source reports that Archbishop Thazhath had directed Msgr Narikulam to reopen the Basilica and ensure the celebration of the Holy Qurbana in the uniform mode. Msgr Narikulam told the Apostolic Administrator that he was unable to carry out the directive because of resistance from priests and parishioners, and he called for dialogue to address the differences and restore confidence between the ecclesiastical leadership and the local Church. [Romans 12:18]
Msgr Narikulam challenged the transfer through the Church’s canonical judicial system, approaching the Apostolic Signatura for redress. The proceedings became part of a wider controversy over disciplinary measures against clergy in the archdiocese.
The case also has a wider background. In December 2024, a disciplinary tribunal was established in the archdiocese to deal with priests accused of disobeying ecclesiastical directives concerning the uniform liturgy. Its proceedings came under scrutiny over alleged procedural irregularities. Following an appeal by its presiding judge, Fr James Mathew Pampara, the Apostolic Signatura intervened on October 1, 2025, suspending proceedings in the special tribunal, prohibiting the initiation of new cases and directing that the relevant files be submitted for examination. The two pending cases were later referred to the ordinary Metropolitan Tribunal of the archdiocese. The source states that Major Archbishop Raphael Thattil issued a decree on September 30, 2026, dissolving the special tribunal.
Renewed efforts to address the liturgical differences also form part of the context. In August 2026, the Synod of Bishops of the Syro-Malabar Church reaffirmed an agreement reached in June 2025. It allows parishes in the archdiocese to continue celebrating the Holy Qurbana with the priest facing the congregation throughout, while requiring at least one celebration in the uniform mode on Sundays and holy days of obligation. The source describes this arrangement as an attempt to accommodate the pastoral concerns of the archdiocese while maintaining the Synod’s position on liturgical uniformity.
St Mary’s Cathedral Basilica, the principal church of the Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese, remained closed for an extended period during the confrontation. Its reopening and the subsequent resumption of public worship are described in the source as important stages in efforts to restore normal ecclesiastical life.
Msgr Narikulam will return to the pastoral leadership of the Basilica on November 12, more than three years after his removal in July 2023.
Source: Read the original report