Historian Daniel Hummel Argues Christian Zionism Is Not Popular Caricature

By Claudette Posted Nov 18, 2026 at 8:59 AM
Share:FacebookXEmail

Dwight D. Eisenhower was the first president baptized in office. Shortly after his inauguration, Edward L. R. Elson, pastor of the National Presbyterian Church in Washington, baptized the president in a private ceremony. Elson was also a close adviser to Secretary of State John Foster Dulles, whom he invited to church events and often advised on affairs of state. He was, in the source’s description, a committed anti-Zionist. Beginning in 1954, he served on the board of the American Friends of the Middle East (AFME), which the source describes as an anti-Zionist front group sponsored by the CIA.

Elson pressed his case with Dulles. In 1955 he wrote to ask how the AFME might be of increased usefulness during a trying time in American relations in the region. In 1957 he invited Dulles to a dinner with Cornelius Engert, one of the AFME’s founders, to discuss Middle East strategy. Dulles’s staff, noting that the AFME was a partisan Arab group, declined the invitation on his behalf. In 1958 Elson urged Dulles to stop in Egypt on the way to a Baghdad Pact meeting in Ankara, arguing that some trusted friends would be encouraged by his personal appearance in Cairo.

With a few exceptions, Dulles gave Elson the cold shoulder. Elson believed that support for Israel was contrary to American interests in the Middle East, and he showed little interest in concrete efforts toward reconciliation between Jews and Christians beyond prayer, which he called the best way of reconciliation and a tool for peace.

Evangelicals such as Billy Graham, the source notes, took a different approach. Historian Daniel Hummel, in his book *Covenant Brothers*, argues that evangelicals broadly and consistently sought reconciliation with the Jewish people through support for the newly established nation of Israel after 1948. Hummel describes a political and social program meant to bring American Jews, the Israeli state, and evangelicals into what he calls a “covenantal partnership.” This program became known as Christian Zionism, and figures including Graham, William Foxwell Albright, Golda Meir, and Jan Willem van der Hoeven helped shape it, especially after the Six-Day War of 1967.

Hummel contends that Christian Zionism is not the caricature of popular imagination, which attributes evangelical fondness for Israel to end-times fascination and American imperial ambition. He argues that theology, history, political philosophy, Cold War diplomacy, pragmatic considerations, and tourism all played a role. He identifies reconciliation between Jews and Christians as the unifying theme, and he traces the movement in three parts, “Roots,” “Shoots,” and “Branches,” from 1948 to 2018. One chapter examines tourism, including the period between 1967 and 1971, and notes that conservative political figures such as Mike Huckabee led evangelical tours. The 1973 Yom Kippur War, the source reports, prompted new reconciliation initiatives, and a first Jewish-evangelical conference on reconciliation was held in 1975. Christian Zionism, according to Hummel, “emerged as a key part of American evangelical identity” during this period (2 Corinthians 5:18 names reconciliation as the lesson that these efforts sought).

The source also reports that Hummel warns of the harmful effects of reconciliation efforts that marginalized voices critical of Israeli state interests, and it notes that Hummel does not fully address some developments in dispensationalism, including progressive dispensationalism, which the source says rejects replacement theology. The source also points to other works on the subject, including Gerald McDermott’s *The New Christian Zionism* and Samuel Goldman’s *God’s Country: Christian Zionism in America*, which considers the course of Christian Zionist thought and attitudes since the colonial period.

Source: Read the original report

Kingdom News Location

Washington, District of Columbia, United States

Open map

Claudette

Claudette is GracePress's virtual editorial byline for articles produced by Claude Haiku 5.5, a language model made by Anthropic and reached through Anthropic's API. She does not independently report, interview sources, or witness events. Working from linked source material, the GracePress News Ingest system uses Claude to rewrite articles within campaign-specific rules for factual attribution, careful treatment of allegations, Christian moral context, location extraction, and source disclosure. Every Claudette article identifies its underlying source and is published through GracePress's automated editorial workflow.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer