
Church of the Nazarene Board Finds Former Minister Thomas Oord Guilty, Revokes Credentials After Trial in Boise, Idaho
Thomas Jay Oord, a theologian and former Church of the Nazarene minister from Nampa, Idaho, was the subject of a church disciplinary trial in Boise, Idaho. Oord is a former professor at Northwest Nazarene University. According to the Idaho Statesman, he describes his views and advocacy for LGBTQ+ people as “queer-affirming,” and the church trial centered on those views. Oord was asked to resign from the university in 2014 over his teachings on the nature of evil and God’s omnipotence. He was then laid off under a workforce reduction, and for three years afterward he worked with the university’s online arm under a severance agreement. Two church members raised concerns about his stance on LGBTQ+ issues in the winter of 2021.
Before the trial, the Idaho Statesman reported that if Oord were found guilty, he could lose his credentials as an ordained elder, his church membership, and the right to preach or teach at any Nazarene institution or church. The trial was to include witnesses from both sides, and a board of church officials from across the Western United States would decide his case. Hearing testimony from both sides is a matter of fairness in the process (Proverbs 18:17).
The Church of the Nazarene Regional Board of Discipline delivered its verdict on the evening of Saturday, July 28, according to MinistryWatch. The trial itself took place in Boise on Thursday, July 25, which MinistryWatch reported. A later Idaho Statesman report gave the trial date as July 25 and said the board found Oord guilty. That report’s account of the sanction is incomplete in the material available, so the details of the board’s action are drawn from MinistryWatch: the court stripped Oord of his preaching credentials and expelled him from membership in the denomination, which MinistryWatch described as having 2.5 million members.
MinistryWatch reported that the church court, made up of four clergy and two lay people, found Oord guilty of conduct unbecoming a minister and of teaching doctrines out of harmony with the church’s doctrinal statement. The court emailed him its five-page verdict on Saturday night, July 27, according to the same report, which also describes the verdict as delivered on July 28. The two dates in that account do not match, and the sources supplied do not resolve the difference.
The court cited a book Oord wrote with his daughter, Alexa Oord, titled “Why the Church of the Nazarene Should Be Fully LGBTQ+ Affirming,” which it found particularly egregious. The court also said Oord showed absolutely no repentance or willingness to submit to church authority.
MinistryWatch also reported that last year the church defrocked Selden Kelley, a San Diego Nazarene minister, after a guilty verdict.
Sources (3):
- ‘Queer-affirming’ Nazarene minister on trial in Boise this week over LGBTQ+ support | Opinion (idahostatesman.com)
- Nazarene church put Idaho minister on trial for LGBTQ+ support. Here’s the verdict (idahostatesman.com)
- Church of the Nazarene Expels LGBTQ-Affirming Theologian – MinistryWatch (ministrywatch.com)