
States Use Catholic Clergy Abuse Lists in Job Screens
States face a difficult question: whether to screen former clergy members who seek licenses for jobs that put them in contact with children, and if so, how. The question follows revelations that scores of Roman Catholic priests and religious workers credibly accused of child sexual abuse are living unsupervised in communities across the country.
An Associated Press investigation last fall found that nearly 200 accused clergy members had been granted teaching, mental health or social work licenses, with roughly six dozen still holding valid licenses to work in those fields in 2019. Since then, at least 20 states have begun using church-released lists of priests and employees who faced credible allegations to screen applicants or check for state teaching, foster care and therapy licenses, and in some cases have revoked credentials. Protecting children from those with credible allegations against them is a concern that the Bible treats with gravity (Mark 9:42).
More than 170 dioceses and religious orders have released lists of clergy members they found to be credibly accused of abuses ranging from rape to child pornography. The lists include more than 5,300 priests, clergy members and a handful of lay employees, more than 2,000 of whom are still living. Because most of those named were never convicted of a crime, the AP investigation found, the allegations never appeared in licensing background checks.
Church and law enforcement officials have said there is little they can do to monitor or restrict the nearly 1,700 mostly former clergy members the AP found living without supervision. Many voluntarily left the church or were laicized, a status that permanently restricts them from the priesthood and returns them to private citizenship.
For nearly two decades, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, known as SNAP, has advocated for church officials to report allegations to law enforcement, child protection and other state agencies. The group says state agencies have not yet determined their role in responding to clerical abuse. David Clohessy, the former executive director of SNAP, who leads its St. Louis chapter, said, “These agencies need to refocus their priorities. They’re here to protect the public from predators, not to make getting a license to be a shrink or doctor easier.”
AP reporters contacted agencies in all 50 states and found that dozens have started discussions, checked their lists of licenses for named clergy, or begun using the diocesan lists released in their areas to flag applications. The changes to license reviews and background checks span all areas of state licensing, from foster care to boards of education, in states from New Hampshire to Oklahoma. In Ohio, Gov. Mike DeWine ordered the state Department of Job and Family Services to review how county-level child service agencies and private placement agencies could incorporate the diocesan lists into background checks used to determine where children are placed. A spokesman for DeWine said the directive came after the AP published its investigation and called the action “warranted to protect Ohio’s children.”
A comprehensive review is complicated because no official national master database of accused clergy exists, so states must choose how many of the more than 170 lists to consult. Pennsylvania’s education licensing department has conducted perhaps the most extensive search of its licensing database, checking for nearly 500 clergy members’ names released in three state or local grand jury reports over the past decade, including the 2018 Pennsylvania attorney general’s grand jury report on how abuse allegations were handled in six dioceses. The department revoked or accepted the surrender of three licenses from former clergy members and is investigating a dozen other licensees. That first effort did not include lay church employees named on diocesan lists or former priests who may have moved to Pennsylvania from other states and sought licenses.
Dylan Klapmeier, a spokesman for the Montana Department of Public Instruction, said the agency checked its list of credentialed teachers against names issued by two Montana dioceses and found no matches. He said the lack of a national list makes the work harder, noting that “there are lots of places to hide here.”
For many education and licensing departments, using the diocesan lists is difficult because state laws govern what may be considered when deciding whether to issue or revoke a license. Some agencies allow only criminal background checks, while others may also check the state’s child abuse and neglect database.
Source: Read the original report