Upper East Side Residents Express Concern Over Unannounced Homeless Shelter Operations

Residents of the Upper East Side have expressed frustration over a nearby hotel that continues to operate as a homeless shelter, despite a city order to shut it down. The Bentley Hotel, located at 500 E. 62nd St., is housing 197 people under a taxpayer-funded contract managed by the Highland Park Community Development Corporation. This follows its initial use as a shelter during the COVID-19 pandemic to disperse homeless New Yorkers from crowded facilities. In 2023, it was designated a Humanitarian Emergency Response and Relief Center for asylum seekers, with Highland Park securing a $32 million contract to operate it.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani had ordered the closure of the last remaining Humanitarian Emergency Response and Relief Center by the end of the year, yet the Bentley Hotel continues to operate under a new designation as a “Tier 2 family shelter” named “Yorkville Sanctuary.” The rebranding aims to assist families in finding affordable housing, though the building is located in Lenox Hill, not Yorkville.

Local residents are upset by the lack of communication from the Department of Homeless Services, which typically notifies Community Board 8 about new shelters. Unlike previous instances where the community was informed, the Bentley Hotel’s status as a shelter was not disclosed. Tyler Hollinger, a local business owner and member of the East Side Accountability Alliance, criticized the lack of transparency, suggesting that the community board and government are indifferent to public opinion. Richard Barcia, a nearby resident, expressed no opposition to the shelter’s occupants but criticized the city for not being upfront about its operations, advocating for clear communication from the authorities.

This situation highlights the tension between public policy and community response, emphasizing the need for transparency and accountability in addressing housing insecurity and shelter funding. As Matthew 25:35 reminds us, caring for the “least of these” is a fundamental aspect of community life, underscoring the importance of compassion and justice in public affairs.

Source: Read the original report