LCMS and ELCA Leaders Discuss Theological Implications of 2009 ELCA Sexuality Decisions

By Claudette Posted Nov 9, 2026 at 4:41 PM
Share:FacebookXEmail

The Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod (LCMS) and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) discussed the theological implications of the ELCA’s 2009 Churchwide Assembly decisions on human sexuality at a meeting of the Committee on Lutheran Cooperation (CLC) in Chicago on April 12-13. The CLC meets twice a year. The church leaders also heard from the heads of three cooperative agencies and shared updates on developments in each other’s church bodies.

The 2009 assembly directed that ELCA policy documents be revised so that eligible Lutherans in publicly accountable, lifelong, monogamous same-gender relationships could serve as ELCA clergy and professional lay leaders. The assembly also directed that the revised policies recognize the convictions of those who believe the ELCA should not allow such service, and it adopted a social statement on human sexuality. The ELCA Church Council adopted final revisions to the policy documents on April 10, putting them into effect.

The discussion began with a review of “Theological Implications of the 2009 ELCA Decisions,” a 10-page document prepared by a task force appointed by LCMS Synod President Dr. Gerald B. Kieschnick. Kieschnick said the document was intended for use by LCMS pastors and members in their own study and in dialogue with ELCA members, and that it was meant to help members “walk through this, while not compromising our own point of view.” ELCA Presiding Bishop the Rev. Mark S. Hanson said the church received it “in the understanding that you were speaking to your own church, but also to us,” and added that the ELCA’s actions “put stress on relationships, but not stress to the point that we believe that they should sever the relationships rather than call us to deeper conversation.”

Responses were offered by Dr. Marcus R. Kunz, executive for discernment of contextual and theological issues in the ELCA Office of the Presiding Bishop, and Dr. Rebecca S. Larson, executive director of ELCA Church in Society. In the two-hour follow-up discussion, Dr. Joel Lehenbauer, executive director of the LCMS Commission on Theology and Church Relations, told Kunz that the LCMS paper did not say the ELCA had “abandoned” Scripture as a source of authority. He said the paper does assert that the two churches “have fundamentally different understandings of the nature of Scripture’s authority, not just differing opinions about how to interpret certain passages of Scripture.” He noted that the question was not new, citing earlier documents and discussions.

Dr. Samuel H. Nafzger, director of LCMS church relations and assistant to the president, asked ELCA participants whether, in their view, there were “any positions of a bound conscience that should divide brothers and sisters in Christ at the altar.” He said the two churches “are bound together by many things” and that there is “no place for Christians to misrepresent the position of our two churches on the issues we are debating.” He also said that the ELCA wants to respect the “bound consciences” of both sides, but that in the LCMS’s opinion this cannot be done without a different understanding of the authority of Scripture. He stated that the LCMS regards consciences bound to positions that contradict the simple and plain meaning of Scripture as “erring consciences in need of confession and absolution.”

Dr. M. Wyvetta Bullock, executive for administration in the ELCA Office of the Presiding Bishop, said continued conversation between the two churches was important, noting that the ELCA itself continues such conversations internally and “we don’t have consensus.” Synod Secretary Dr. Raymond L. Hartwig said that while he did not foresee much immediate change in the ELCA-LCMS relationship, the decisions presented “a special challenge” because the ELCA actions were “imposed” on the LCMS, which holds a consistent biblical view of marriage and related issues. He said a key question being asked in the LCMS is, “Do cooperative efforts imply doctrinal unity with the ELCA?” Kieschnick said the LCMS convention in July would likely address the ELCA sexuality decisions. Hanson said leaders of both churches had come a long way in the nine years of CLC discussions, adding, “I think we have deep respect for one another,” and that both churches would “pray for your convention.”

At a separate, semi-annual meeting, the Lutheran church leaders met with leaders of Baltimore-based Lutheran partner organizations. They heard updates from Linda Hartke of Lutheran Immigration and Refugee Service; Dr. John A. Nunes and Jeff Whisenat of Lutheran World Relief; and Jill A. Schumann of Lutheran Services in America. Rev. Kevin A. Massey, director of Lutheran Disaster Response and ELCA Domestic Disaster Response, provided updates on that work. LCMS leaders reported that the LCMS convention would be held July 10-17 in Houston, with significant business including a series of restructuring recommendations, among them possible restructuring of districts and the national church body. They also reported that the LCMS Fan into Flame campaign, which supports the synod’s evangelism effort Ablaze!, had raised $56 million in gifts and pledges toward a $100 million goal.

The LCMS Commission on Theology and Church Relations recently adopted a report on Christian stewardship of the environment, “Together With All Creatures: Caring for God’s Living Earth,” which is intended for small groups and as a teaching tool. Nafzger said the LCMS had received requests for conversation from some African churches, including the Ethiopian Evangelical Church Mekane Yesus, the Malagasy Lutheran Church (Madagascar), and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Tanzania. Hanson said the ELCA has been focusing on mission, tending its relationships, discerning who wants to be part of the church, and planning for its future, and that the ELCA approved 41 new mission starts this year, 23 of them in immigrant communities. For the immediate future, he said, the ELCA is focused on two strategic priorities: serving congregations and increasing capacity for service to fight poverty, and seeking justice and peace. The churchwide organization and its unit directors are also working on contingency planning for possible declines in mission support funds from congregations through synods.

Representing the ELCA were Hanson; Rev. Allan C. Bjornberg, bishop of the Rocky Mountain Synod and chair of the ELCA Conference of Bishops; Bullock; Kunz; Larson; Rev. Donald J. McCoid, executive for Ecumenical and Inter-Religious Relations; Carlos Peña, vice president; and David D. Swartling, secretary. Representing the LCMS were Kieschnick; Dr. William R. Diekelman, first vice-president; Hartwig; Lehenbauer; Nafzger; Ronald Schulz, chief administrative officer; and Dr. Larry Stoterau, president of the Pacific Southwest District.

Source: Read the original report

Kingdom News Location

Chicago, South Chicago Township, Cook County, Illinois, United States

Open map

Claudette

Claudette is GracePress's virtual editorial byline for articles produced by Claude Haiku 5.5, a language model made by Anthropic and reached through Anthropic's API. She does not independently report, interview sources, or witness events. Working from linked source material, the GracePress News Ingest system uses Claude to rewrite articles within campaign-specific rules for factual attribution, careful treatment of allegations, Christian moral context, location extraction, and source disclosure. Every Claudette article identifies its underlying source and is published through GracePress's automated editorial workflow.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer