Exclusive Brethren Used Thompson and Clark to Surveil Ex-Members, Report Says

By Claudette Posted Nov 19, 2026 at 4:05 AM
Share:FacebookXEmail

The Exclusive Brethren church has been using the private investigators Thompson and Clark to spy on former members, according to an RNZ Morning Report investigation by Nicky Hager broadcast on 20 April 2021. Over the past two years, the firm has reportedly conducted hundreds of hours of surveillance on former members who have criticised the church, which the report describes as cult-like. Investigators have watched ex-Brethren from cars and parked surveillance vans and photographed people entering and leaving their homes. The surveillance reportedly began in mid-2019 against a visiting British ex-member and then extended to local former members.

Thompson and Clark had earlier drawn public attention for spying on Greenpeace and on Christchurch earthquake insurance claimants. A State Services Commission (SSC) inquiry was later launched into government agencies’ use of security consultants. SSC head Peter Hughes condemned government organisations that paid the firm for “surveillance of a person just because they are lawfully exercising their democratic rights – including their right to freedom of expression, association and right to protest.” Government agencies were forbidden to use the investigators. The report states that the firm has continued similar operations for private clients, including the Exclusive Brethren.

According to the report, the firm has built dossiers on at least 20 ex-members who are known or believed to be critics of the church. These files reportedly combine information from monitoring social media, public records and street surveillance with information supplied by church leadership. The report says its account of the spying operations was pieced together from confidential past and present Exclusive Brethren sources, industry sources and fieldwork.

The church is headed by Sydney businessman Bruce Hales, known as the Elect Vessel or Man of God, according to the report. The report states that members must obtain his permission before they marry, that members’ internet access is controlled on devices leased from a Brethren company, and that he does not tolerate doubt or questioning of his authority. Members who express doubts or question leadership may be “withdrawn from,” meaning expelled without right of defence and cut off from contact with Brethren family members. Ex-members told the report that many people around New Zealand have been separated in this way from parents, spouses and children, and that the threat of this separation hangs over the membership. Ex-members say church leaders still fear them as a threat to their control. Families cut apart by such withdrawal carry a lasting sorrow, a loss that calls for comfort (Psalm 34:18).

The report says surveillance teams kept watch on ex-members’ homes, sometimes from early morning until late at night, and followed their cars and tracked them on public transport. It states that some of this surveillance has led to protracted legal and other retaliation against ex-Brethren from the church hierarchy.

The main allegations were put to Thompson and Clark director Gavin Clark, who was asked whether he disputed them. He did not respond to the allegations directly. In an email, he wrote that it was “important to emphasise that [the 2018 SSC inquiry] report does not suggest surveillance can never occur.” He said the company “provides services to protect individuals, operations and assets from being impacted by unlawful activity,” and that Thompson & Clark “always strived to operate within the law and the rules and regulations of our industry.”

Plymouth Brethren Christian Church spokesperson Doug Watt said: “While we cannot comment on the actions of every individual within our Church, it is certainly true to say that the Church leadership has absolutely no knowledge or involvement in the matters you have described.” He added: “Just like any church, we are sad if someone leaves us, but wish them all of the best in their lives…. We strive to live a community-minded life, following the teachings of the Holy Bible and centred around values of care, charity and compassion.”

One ex-Brethren on the Thompson and Clark target list told RNZ: “People who don’t know the Exclusive Brethren, I tell them it’s like North Korea: a dictatorship where one man has total control, the Internet is controlled, members live in fear and if anyone threatens the leadership they’re punished and cut off from their families.”

Source: Read the original report

Kingdom News Location

New Zealand

Open map

Claudette

Claudette is GracePress's virtual editorial byline for articles produced by Claude Haiku 5.5, a language model made by Anthropic and reached through Anthropic's API. She does not independently report, interview sources, or witness events. Working from linked source material, the GracePress News Ingest system uses Claude to rewrite articles within campaign-specific rules for factual attribution, careful treatment of allegations, Christian moral context, location extraction, and source disclosure. Every Claudette article identifies its underlying source and is published through GracePress's automated editorial workflow.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer